Shelby unpacks the latest in Taylor Swift fan theories (5:25). Matt catches us up on the Jussie Smollet case (12:48). Shelby revels in the latest Kardashian scandal (18:38). And Matt spills the beans on the Oscar gift bags (27:18). Then it’s time to recap the 91st Academy Awards, from all the things that worked and all the things that didn’t. Plus it’s a game of Would It Have Worked where we revisit all the things that could have been and the winner of our giveaway. For Love It or Hate It (1:19:41) Matt recommends one of the Oscar animated shorts and Shelby finally watches *The Americans*. ...

Buckle up, this one's a doozy. Shelby and Matt rank every movie they saw in 2018 from worst to best. THe catch: it's the average of both. Who's taste will come out on top? To skip around in the bloodbath here are the timestamps for our top 113 (6:15), 100 (20:04), 75 (47:48), 50 (1:10:04), 25 (1:37:35), and 10 (1:53:42). ...

Dina Lohan might be being catfished (5:00). Ryan Murphy got Matt’s hopes up about *Scream Queens* (8:36). Justin Bieber and Hailey Baldwin are working hard on their marriage (13:01). And celebrities are over F*ckJerry (20:14). But everything is awesome when they start talking about *The Lego Movie 2: The Second Part* (27:05) and whether or not this sequel can stack up to the original. For Love it or Hate It, Shelby does a deep dive into Ariana Grande’s new album, *Thank U Next* (1:06:34) and Matt cleanses his pallet with a recommendation for Troye Sivan and Lauv’s “I’m So Tired...” ...

Shelby and Matt discuss Ariana Grande’s love of Japanese BBQ (3:48), Adam Levine’s half-hearted Halftime show (7:53), Liam Neeson (16:00), and the New Yorker story on Dan Mallory (20:34). Then it’s time to get into *Serenity* (25:45), the Matthew McConaughey and Anne Hathaway thriller no one’s seeing but everyone’s talking about. Spoiler warning at 37:22. For Love It or Hate It (57:54) it’s all about Netflix as Matt rails on *The Ballad of Buster Scruggs* and Shelby recommends *Abducted in Plain Sight*. ...

Matt runs wild with news of a *Princess Diaries* sequel (4:58) while Shelby dreams up some drama between Kim Kardashian and Taylor Swift (8:50). *Rent Live* reminds us all to always have a backup plan (11:21) while Pete Davidson milks the Ariana breakup for some comedy material (13:56). But Shelby and Matt are *split* on how they feel about the Feature Presentation: *Glass* (16:01). Is the M. N. Shyamalan trilogy finale half full or half empty? SPOILERS ABOUND (24:51). For Love It or Hate It (52:51), Matt talks about the documentary *Minding the Gap* and Shelby recommends Netflix’s new zombie series *Kingdom*. ...

It’s bad news as Shelby and Matt catch up on Chris Brown (1:59), Bryan Singer (5:29), and the *Cats* movie that is definitely happening (7:34). But at least there’s Ariana Grande’s newest album to look forward to (9:54). And then for the feature presentation (12:23) they’re talking about all the nominations for the 91st Annual Academy awards -- both what was nominated and what they wish had made the cut. For Love It or Hate It (1:02:24) Shelby gives *Riverdale* a chance and Matt reviews *Fyre* on Netflix. ...